List of the Top 9 Safest Places to Live in Long Island (2023)

If you’re planning to move to Long Island, it’s crucial to consider living in a city or neighborhood with a low crime rate. Fortunately, we’ve compiled a list of the top nine safest places to call home on Long Island. This list will aid in your search for a secure and peaceful area to reside in.

9 Safest Places to Live in Long Island

1. 1. Roslyn
   2. Greenport
   3. Brookhaven
   4. Manhasset
   5. Great Neck
   6. Jericho
   7. Huntington
   8. Merrick
   9. Plainview

1. Roslyn

Located on Long Island’s North Shore, Roslyn offers a unique blend of historical roots, remote charm, and abundant urban amenities. With a population of just under 3,000 people, this historic village boasts a charming small-town atmosphere that is hard to come by. In addition to its downtown shopping and eating scene, Roslyn is home to several attractions, such as the Hampstead Harbor and the Robeson-Williams Grist Mill. It’s no surprise that Roslyn is considered the safest place to live on Long Island, with an overall crime rate that is approximately 84% lower than the island’s average. If you’re looking for a place that combines safety and small-town charm, Roslyn is the perfect destination.

2. Greenport

Greenport, a small village located on Long Island’s northern fork, is considered one of the safest neighborhoods in the area. Historically, Greenport was known for its thriving oyster, whaling, maritime construction, and railroad industries. Today, it is a peaceful community with a population of approximately 2,600 people, making it a popular tourist destination. Residents and tourists alike can enjoy strolling down one of the many boardwalks or relaxing by the water. Greenport also boasts several museums, restaurants, and cafes for visitors to explore. With a crime rate 73% below Long Island’s average, Greenport is an ideal choice for those seeking a slower-paced lifestyle and a safe community.

3. Brookhaven

Brookhaven, a neighborhood located in Suffolk County, is known for being one of the safest places to live on Long Island. It comprises of nine different villages and fifty unincorporated hamlets and stretches between the island’s north and south shores. Brookhaven is famous for its local attractions like the Brookhaven National Laboratory and Southaven County Park. Residents of Brookhaven can enjoy access to both the Long Island Sound and the Great South Bay, which makes it a popular spot among water sports enthusiasts. The area is known for its numerous beaches and is a favorite spot among surfers, swimmers, sailors, and fishermen. With crime rates 69% lower than the Long Island average, Brookhaven is a secure choice for anyone looking to reside in Long Island.

4. Manhasset

Manhasset isn’t just a safe location, it’s also known for its affluence. Positioned on the inner segment of Manhasset Bay, this city boasts luxury stores, high-end restaurants, and has even earned the moniker, “Rodeo Drive of the East Coast.” The area is highly sought after by shoppers and food enthusiasts alike, who flock to the renowned shopping district, the Miracle Mile. With over 60 international boutiques, residents can enjoy a truly exceptional shopping experience. Additionally, with an average home value of $1.9 million and crime rates approximately 65% below the island average, Manhasset is an ideal location for affluent individuals and families.

5. Great Neck

Great Neck, situated opposite to Manhasset, is also one of the safest cities on Long Island. For those who cherish waterfront access, this place is a perfect abode. The area is renowned for its picturesque waterfront vistas and access to the North Shore. Interestingly, it is believed that F. Scott Fitzgerald’s “The Great Gatsby” was inspired by this very place. Great Neck offers a tranquil lifestyle away from the commotion of the inner cities, while still providing access to urban amenities, making it an ideal location to reside. Whether it’s charming bungalows or Tudor-style homes, buyers can choose from an array of architectural styles. Moreover, with a crime rate 62% below the island’s average, Great Neck is a safe haven for those who prioritize safety.

6. Jericho

Jericho, situated in the central part of Long Island, is a peaceful small town that offers a safe living environment. The city, located between Hampstead and Oyster Bay, is approximately 30 miles from Manhattan and is home to over 13,000 people. Jericho’s exceptional school systems and family-friendly atmosphere make it a popular choice among young couples and families. The area offers many local amenities, including Jericho Commons, Active Kidz Long Island, Old Westbury Gardens, and more. Additionally, Jericho’s crime rates are approximately 62% lower than the island’s average, making it an ideal location for current and future parents.

7. Huntington

If you’re looking for a safe and comfortable place to live in Long Island’s North Shore area, Huntington is definitely worth considering. Not only is it conveniently located near Manhattan, but it also boasts a waterfront community with a rich history in agriculture and shipping. Today, it’s known for its stunning beaches, marinas, parks, and harbors, all of which are major draws for residents and visitors alike. In addition, Huntington is home to several local attractions, including the Paramount Theatre, Oheka Castle, and the Heckscher Museum of Art. What’s more, crime rates in this city are significantly lower than the island’s average, making it an even more appealing place to call home.

8. Merrick

Merrick, located along the southern tip of the island, is a great option for those seeking safety and a suburban atmosphere while still being close to New York City. This city is famous for its beaches and fantastic weather, and residents can enjoy various seaside activities such as fishing and swimming. The Cow Meadow Preserve, Merrick Road Park, Marshall County Historical Museum, and the Memphis Zoo and Aquarium are local attractions that are worth a visit. With crime rates remaining 58% below the island average, Merrick is an ideal area for those who prioritize safety.

9. Plainview

Plainview, located in Nassau County, is an excellent choice for those seeking an active lifestyle and a safe community. Originally established as a farming community, this city is about 27 miles from New York City and home to around 26,000 people. The area boasts a variety of local parks and activity spaces, including tennis courts, baseball and softball fields, racquetball/handball courts, Olympic-sized pools, and more. Cantiague Park and West Hills County Park are among the several parks in the area. Moreover, Plainview’s crime rates are 57% below the island’s average, making it an ideal and secure place for fitness enthusiasts.

Also Read:

• List Of Top10 Safest Cities in Alabama (2023)
• List of the Top 10 Safest Cities in Connecticut for 2023
• List Of The Top 10 Safest Neighborhoods in Georgia in 2023