Safest Places to Live in Long Island

Top 9 Safest Places to Live in Long Island (2023)

Are you considering a move to Long Island? With its beautiful beaches, vibrant communities, and proximity to New York City, it’s no wonder why so many people are drawn to this area. However, safety is always a top priority when choosing where to live. That’s why we have compiled a list of the top 9 safest places to call home in Long Island for 2023.
These areas have it all, from low crime rates to excellent schools and friendly neighbourhoods. Whether you’re a young professional looking for an exciting city vibe or a family seeking peace and tranquillity, we’ve got you covered with our comprehensive guide to the safest places in Long Island.

9 Safest Places to Live on Long Island


Located on Long Island’s North Shore, Roslyn is a historic village that offers a charming small-town atmosphere that is hard to come by. With just under 3,000 people, the area boasts a perfect blend of historical roots, remote charm, and plentiful urban amenities. Its downtown shopping and dining scene is a must-visit, as are its attractions, such as Hampstead Harbor and the Robeson-Williams Grist Mill. Roslyn is the safest place to live on Long Island, with an overall crime rate of about 84% lower than the average. Roslyn is the perfect destination if you’re looking for a place that combines safety with small-town charm.


Greenport, a small village located on the northern fork of Long Island, is considered one of the area’s safest neighbourhoodsa. It has a rich history, having once been a hub for oyster farming, whaling, maritime construction, and railroads. Today, it has a population of around 2,600 people and is a popular tourist destination. In Greenport, residents can relax by the water or stroll along its many boardwalks. The neighbourhood also boasts various museums, restaurants, and cafes. With a crime rate approximately 73% below the Long Island average, Greenport is a peaceful option for those who prefer a slow-paced lifestyle.


Brookhaven, a neighbourhood in Suffolk County, is considered one of the safest places to live on Long Island. This area comprises nine individual villages and fifty unincorporated hamlets, stretching between the island’s north and south shores. Brookhaven National Laboratory and Southaven County Park are popular local attractions, while its residents enjoy easy access to both the Long Island Sound and the Great South Bay. With its numerous beaches, this neighbourhood is a favourite among water sports enthusiasts, including surfers, swimmers, sailors, and fishermen. The crime rate in Brookhaven is 69% below the Long Island average, making it a secure choice for anyone considering living on the island.


Manhasset is not just a safe area but also renowned for its affluence. The city is situated on the inner stretch of Manhasset Bay and is well-known for its high-end restaurants and luxurious stores. It has even earned the nickname “Rodeo Drive of the East Coast”. The Miracle Mile, the city’s famous shopping district, draws shoppers and food enthusiasts from all over. With more than 60 international boutiques, residents can enjoy a unique shopping experience. Manhasset is the perfect haven for wealthy individuals and families, with an average home value of $1.9 million and crime rates 65% below the island average.

Great Neck

Great Neck is situated across from Manhasset and is also one of the safest cities on Long Island. This area particularly appeals to those who enjoy the waterfront as it offers stunning views and access to the North Shore. Interestingly, it’s speculated that F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel, The Great Gatsby, was inspired by this location. Great Neck provides a perfect mix of relaxed living and urban amenities, making it a highly sought-after area. Homebuyers can choose from architectural styles, from charming bungalows to Tudor-style homes. Moreover, with a crime rate that is 62% below the island’s average, Great Neck is an excellent option for those who prioritize safety.


Located in the central part of Long Island, Jericho is a small and peaceful town that offers a safe environment for its residents. It is situated between Hampstead and Oyster Bay. It is approximately 30 miles from Manhattan, making it an ideal location for those who prefer a quiet lifestyle away from the hustle and bustle of the city.

The city’s population of just over 13,000 comprises young couples and families who appreciate the excellent school systems and family-friendly atmosphere. Jericho is also home to several local amenities that residents can enjoy, such as the Jericho Commons, Active Kidz Long Island, and Old Westbury Gardens. With crime rates 62% lower than Long Island’s average, Jericho is a top choice for parents who want to raise their families in a safe and secure environment.


Huntington is located on Long Island’s North Shore, a safe and highly desirable neighbourhood. Thanks to its proximity to Manhattan, residents can enjoy a quick and easy commute into the city. Originally known as a hub for agriculture and shipping, Huntington is now a thriving waterfront community, home to some of Long Island’s most stunning beaches, marinas, parks, and harbours.

The Paramount Theatre, Oheka Castle, and the Heckscher Museum of Art are just a few local attractions that draw visitors to this charming city. With crime rates falling 59% below the island’s average, Huntington is considered one of the safest places to live on Long Island.


Merrick, situated along the southern tip of the island, is a top choice for those seeking safety. This city is renowned for its beaches and pleasant weather, providing its residents with a suburban ambience while still being in proximity to New York City. The Cow Meadow Preserve, Merrick Road Park, Marshall County Historical Museum, and the Memphis Zoo and Aquarium are among the local attractions in the area. Furthermore, individuals can engage in various seaside activities, including swimming and fishing. With crime rates approximately 58% below the island average, Merrick is a secure location for living.


Plainview, situated in Nassau County, is ideal for those who prefer an active lifestyle. Initially, it was established as a farming community about 27 miles from New York City. With a population of around 26,000, Plainview offers an array of local parks and activity spaces. It boasts numerous tennis courts, baseball and softball fields, racquetball/handball courts, Olympic-sized pools, and more. Besides, the city has several parks, including Cantiague Park and West Hills County Park. Moreover, the area has a crime rate of 57% below the island’s average, making it a secure destination for fitness enthusiasts.

Also Read:

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *